What to Expect from These Spooky Treats

• Taste: Prepare your taste buds for a delightful medley of flavors and textures! Each spoonful delivers creamy, rich chocolate pudding, perfectly complemented by the satisfying crunch of Oreo cookie bits. The special touch comes from a delicious peanut butter cookie on top, adorned with a playful gummy worm and a sweet mini pumpkin candy. It’s a fantastic combination that hits all the right notes for a Halloween-themed dessert.
• Ease: This is truly a beginner-friendly recipe, making it perfect for novice bakers and little helpers. There’s absolutely no cooking involved, which means less time in the kitchen and more time enjoying the festive fun. The only “cooking” you’ll do is a quick melt of chocolate for decorating, which is incredibly straightforward.
• Time: As a no-bake Halloween treat, these pudding cups are incredibly quick to prepare and assemble. You can have a full batch of 12 servings ready and decorated in less than 30 minutes! This efficiency makes them ideal for last-minute party needs or simply a fun, spontaneous activity with the kids.

1. Step 1: Crush the Oreos. Begin by placing 35-40 Oreos into a gallon-sized zip-close bag. Ensure the bag is sealed completely to prevent any crumbs from escaping. Now, get to crushing! You can do this by hand, breaking them into smaller pieces, or for a more uniform “dirt” texture, use a rolling pin to crush them until they resemble small, pea-sized crumbles. This is often a favorite task for little helpers!

2. Step 2: Prepare and Melt White Chocolate. Divide your white and semi-sweet chocolate chips into two separate small plastic zip-close bags or disposable frosting bags. Start with the white chocolate for your mummy cookies. Place the bag of white chocolate chips in the microwave and heat for about 20-30 seconds. Gently squish the bag to mix the chocolate. If not fully melted, warm for another 5-10 seconds, being very careful not to overheat.

IMPORTANT NOTE: White chocolate is quite delicate! Do not microwave it for longer than 20-40 seconds total, especially initially. Overheating white chocolate will cause it to “seize” – it will become thick, crumbly, and unusable for piping. It melts much faster and at a lower temperature than regular chocolate.

3. Step 3: Decorate Mummy Cookies. Lay out about 12-15 Nutter Butter cookies on a plate or a sheet of parchment paper. Once your white chocolate is melted and smooth, snip a tiny hole in the corner of the bag. Drizzle the melted white chocolate across each cookie in a sideways motion. For a more authentic “mummy” look, you can then drizzle diagonally to create crisscross patterns, leaving a small space for “eyes.” Don’t worry about perfection; rustic mummies look charmingly spooky!

4. Step 4: Decorate Gravestone Cookies. Next, arrange 12-15 Milano cookies on a clean plate or parchment paper. Melt the semi-sweet chocolate chips in their separate bag in the microwave for about 30 seconds. Squish the bag gently to ensure the chocolate is fully melted with no hard bits remaining. If needed, warm for another 10-15 seconds. Snip a tiny hole in the corner of this bag and carefully pipe “R.I.P.” onto each Milano cookie to create your gravestones. You can also use this chocolate to dot “eyes” onto your mummy cookies if you prefer.

6. Step 6: Layer the First Components. Now for the fun part: assembly! Gather about 12 clear plastic party cups, ideally short and wide 8 oz cups, as these are easiest for decorating. Start by scooping approximately 2-3 tablespoons of the prepared chocolate pudding into the bottom of each cup. This will form your first “mud” layer. A 3-tablespoon muffin scoop works perfectly for consistent portions.

7. Step 7: Build the Layers. On top of your first pudding layer, sprinkle about 1.5 tablespoons of the crushed Oreos. This creates your initial “dirt” layer. Repeat this process: add another layer of pudding, followed by another layer of crushed Oreos. Before adding the final layer, strategically place a few gummy worms around the edges of the cups. This allows them to peek out from the sides, adding to the creepy-crawly graveyard effect. Finally, add your third and last layers of pudding and crushed Oreos, ensuring the top is covered with “dirt.”

📌 Top Tips & Hacks for the Best Halloween Dirt Cups

To ensure your Halloween dirt pudding cups are a roaring success and look as fantastic as they taste, keep these expert tips in mind:

• Optimal Serving Time: These dirt pudding cups are best served within 2-4 hours of assembly. While they can be refrigerated longer, the Oreos, gummy worms, and decorative cookies can start to soften and lose their distinct textures if left overnight. For the freshest and most appealing presentation, aim to assemble them close to when you plan to enjoy them.
• Smart Prep Ahead: To minimize stress on the day of your Halloween party, you can prepare several components in advance. Make the pudding up to a day before and store it covered in the refrigerator. Crush the Oreos and keep them in an airtight container. Also, prepare and decorate your gravestone and mummy cookies ahead of time; once the chocolate has set, store them in an airtight container at room temperature. Just ensure these tempting treats don’t get ‘mysteriously’ eaten by eager kids (or even husbands!) before the party begins!
• Choose the Right Cups: The type of serving cup makes a big difference for both presentation and ease of decoration. We highly recommend using short, wide, clear plastic 8 oz party cups. Their wider opening makes it much easier to layer the pudding and Oreos, and critically, to arrange your festive cookie and candy decorations without them getting squished or hidden. While smaller 5 oz snack cups can be used for more servings, avoid tall, narrow cups as they make decorating challenging. Small, clear ice cream bowls are another excellent alternative that offers great visibility for your spooky creations.
• Prevent Chocolate Seizing: As noted in the instructions, be extra cautious when melting white chocolate. Microwave in short bursts (20-30 seconds initially, then 5-10 second increments) and stir well in between. If it seizes, it’s unfortunately irreversible, so it’s better to melt it slowly.
• Kid-Friendly Assembly Line: Turn the assembly process into a fun group activity! Set up an assembly line with bowls of pudding, crushed Oreos, gummy worms, and all the decorative candies and cookies. Assign each child a task, or let them build their own cup from start to finish. It’s a fantastic way to engage them and unleash their creativity.

For the best taste and texture, these Halloween dirt pudding cups are ideal when served the same day they are assembled, within 2-4 hours. You can refrigerate them for up to 2 days, but please note that the cookies and Oreo crumbs will gradually become softer the longer they sit. Freezing is generally not recommended as it can significantly alter the pudding’s texture and cause the cookies to become very soggy upon thawing.

Absolutely, yes! While melting chocolate chips is a cost-effective choice if you have them on hand, using store-bought icing in a tube or a piping bag is a perfectly acceptable and convenient alternative. You could also opt for an edible food marker pen to write the “R.I.P.” letters, which offers even more precision and simplicity, especially for kids. The goal is to make these treats fun and easy!

Yes, you definitely can! Feel free to experiment with other instant pudding flavors beyond chocolate. Vanilla, white chocolate, butterscotch, or even pistachio could offer a fun twist. The key is to ensure you are using instant pudding mix, as the “cook and serve” varieties require a different preparation method and do not set up as quickly or easily. Just be aware that different colors might change the “dirt” aesthetic, but the taste will still be great!

Unfortunately, this specific recipe, as written, is not easily adaptable for a vegan diet because instant pudding mix requires dairy milk to set properly. Additionally, many Oreos and other cookies used for decoration, as well as gummy worms, contain animal products. You would need to seek out specific vegan instant pudding mixes, plant-based milks that work with them (check labels carefully), and certified vegan cookies and candies to create a fully vegan version.

Did you try this recipe? If you loved making these fun and spooky Halloween Dirt Pudding Cups, please make sure to leave a ⭐️ star rating and a comment below the recipe card. Your feedback is incredibly valuable, not only do I love hearing from you, but it’s also super helpful to other readers looking for new treats!

📲 FOLLOW Sara on Social! 👋 Facebook, Instagram, or Pinterest to see the latest delicious creations and fun treats from the kitchen!

Halloween Pudding Cups